Well, there is trouble ahead for the Lunatic as well. If the Lunatic was sane, he would be working on a model to predict what the committee will do so I could create an awesome bracketology page with analytics and sage wisdom. Thankfully, we know the answer to this question – the Lunatic is certainly not sane. The blog is calling – so is a desperate plea for sleep that will obviously be ignored.
So lets talk about the long week that the Indiana State Sycamores are having. The Sycamores had a fantastic season, going 28-6 overall and 17-3 in the Missouri Valley to win the regular season championship by a game over Drake. In week 15, they entered both the AP (23) and Coaches (24) Polls. At 22-3 and a NET ranking of 20, it looked like they would be one of those rare mid-major schools that were locks to make the tournament even if disaster happened in the MVC tournament.
But then disaster started. The Sycamores celebrated their entry into the polls as clearly a team with a target on their back. They lost at home by 13 to Illinois State and then on the road by 5 to Southern Illinois. But Indiana State did win the last 4 games to hang on to the MVC regular season title. And then, they fell behind in the MVC championship game by 13 at half to Drake. That lead grew to 18 points with 10 minutes to play before they came alive. A 24-5 run gave them a lead late, but Drake stopped the momentum and finished with a 4 point victory – taking the MVC’s ticket to the dance with them.
With a NET ranking of 29, the Sycamores are still clearly in the discussion. But a closer look at their resume brings more questions than answers. The only quad 1 victory they have is a road win at Bradley on December 2nd. That home loss to Illinois State is classified as a Quad 4 loss (making them only 1 of 2 teams in the top 30 with that bad of a loss). Their only other wins against top 100 teams are their home wins against Drake and Bradley. They do have a 2 point victory against MAC regular season champion Toledo – but with that being a Quad 3 win – it probably won’t help them.
But the toughest point for them is the only two major conference teams they played. They played at Alabama in their second game of the season – where the Tide beat them by 22 points. They then travelled to East Lancing at the end of December, where they were down only 1 point with 7 minutes to played before the Spartans ran away for a 12 point victory. So, the only 2 games they played against teams likely in the tournament as at-large teams led to double digit losses.
And that is the unfairness of being in the Missouri Valley. The Spartans beat Illinois by 8 at home and no one is even questioning if the Illini should be dancing. They also lost on the road by double digits to both Northwestern and Wisconsin – yet, the Spartans are probably safely in the tournament. But imagine how this conversation would be different for the Spartans if they only had those two road games against teams likely in the tournament. People would be asking – who did they beat?
Alabama was 14-2 at home with 11 of those victories being by double digits. Michigan State was 14-4 at home with 10 of those victories being by double digits – and yet those were the only 2 chances the Sycamores had to prove themselves. If 3 or 4 bubble teams had to come to Terre Haute to play, I bet Indiana State probably wins those games.
But major conference teams don’t make the foolish decision of heading to Terre Haute – many won’t even let the Sycamores come to their home to play. So we are left with the question of what is the right picture of this team. Are they the regular season champion who won 28 games that the NET rankings consider one of the top 30 teams in the country? Or are they a team that simply won a lot of games against weak competition and didn’t beat any tournament worthy teams? Sadly, the answer is they are both.
Personally, I hope the Selection Committee gives the Sycamores a chance. But honestly – as I try to predict the bracket, I am not sure they make it – I certainly have seen other regular season mid-major champions with great NET rankings get left out. And that fact will make this week become a very long week in Indiana.